Note: This is Mike’s response to a number of comments posted to Part 1: “Safety cardinal rules for line managers, not just workers.” Read Part 1.
The words ‘rules and compliance’ appear in a number of reader comments. A few argue that adding rules for managers will just result in a more compliance-driven culture and not necessarily a safer one. I agree.
More rules and compliance will not turn a site with a good safety record into a great one. I recognized this when I wrote the article, but I purposely chose a provocative title.
Ideally (and perhaps more rigorously), instead of “rules” I could have challenged readers to consider ways of being as cardinal or primary. This more nuanced wording is more accurate, but it isn’t as punchy. My intent is to challenge managers to stop imposing rigid structures of behavior on their workers without adopting for themselves high standards of ethics, learning and culture change and being accountable for these standards.
So I agree: rules are not the answer, even rules for managers! I appreciate those comments that challenge the thinking (and me by extension!). Other readers make valuable observations:
In my travels I hear divergent views on rules. It seems most line and HSE managers I speak with believe that a foundation of rules and an accompanying structure of discipline for a breach or non-compliance must be in place first. Then we can build a more thoughtful, caring culture.
I also hear people arguing that short-service contractors and employees need to understand the basic requirements and know the immediate consequences of non-compliance. There isn’t time to develop people or contractor companies’ culture with these services.
Are rules a “must-have” and a thoughtful adaptive culture a “nice-to-have”? A few thoughts of my own:
Getting away from punishing errors to learning from them may seem weak to some, but I assure you it will take a lot of courage!
I have seen and heard of managers forgoing punishment for other outcomes that prompt a learning and culture change on their sites. I’d welcome hearing of some examples from readers. And I welcome counter-arguments.
Finally, I want to thank you for commenting. Clearly you care deeply about safety, learning and engaging, not preaching. This is the future of improved safety – your authentic leadership.
Join the Conversation: Are rules a “must-have” and a thoughtful adaptive culture a “nice-to-have”? Leave your comments below.
More articles on HSE:
Photo: Courtesy of JMJ Associates.
Sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua.